Showing posts with label indie artists. Show all posts
Showing posts with label indie artists. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 7, 2009

Agreement Reached on Webcasting Royalty Rates



Ladies and Gentlemen, we have an agreement.

News broke today that "pure play" webcasting services (i.e., the bigger online broadcasters who earn the bulk of their revenue through their services) have reached an agreement with SoundExchange — the nonprofit organization that collects and distributes the digital public performance royalty on behalf of performing artists and sound copyright owners (usually the labels).

Back in 2007, the Copyright Royalty Board — a smallish group of judges tasked with rate setting for online broadcasts — ruled that all webcasters were required to pay a single fee. This per-song royalty would increase to 0.19 cents per song in 2010. Webcasters responded vigorously, claiming that the fees would, in many cases, exceed their entire revenue. FMC also weighed in in the form of Congressional testimony, saying that a one-size-fits all approach to webcasting rates would have a negative impact on a crucial emerging marketplace for independent and niche music.

Since then, rate accommodations have been reached for noncommercial broadcasters' online streams — in January, the Corporation for Public Broadcasting paid $1.85 million for the right to digitally broadcast through 2010. Meanwhile, commercial terrestrial radio agreed to pay 0.15 cent per song for online "simulcasts" of their over-the-air programming, with rates set to increase each year up to 0.25 cent in 2015.

Yet, despite Congressional Acts meant to clear room for negotiation and the implementation of an agreement, there was no consensus between SoundExchange and the bigger webcasters. That is, until now.

This new agreement settles a long-held dispute between the bigger webcasters like Pandora and AOL Radio about how much they should pay. Today's agreement will see those webcasters paying the greater of 25 percent of revenue or a per-song fee which, starts at .08 cent (retroactive to 2006) and eventually scales up to to .14 cent in 2015.

Also of note: companies that offer services beyond streaming radio, such as on-demand subscription and download sites like Rhapsody (who also do streaming), will be eligible for the same rates accepted earlier this year by the National Association of Broadcasters for their simulcasts.

The reaction from all parties involved in negotiations has been generally enthusiastic. “This is definitely the agreement that we’ve been waiting for,” Pandora founder Tim Westergren told the New York Times.

In official statement, John Simson of SoundExchange said the agreement would give webcasters "the opportunity to flesh out various business models and the creators of music the opportunity to share in the success their recordings generate.”

Yet it remains to be seen whether the smaller webcasters will sign on. Billboard has more:

First there's the cap on songs streamed, which for 2009 is based on aggregate tuning hours of 8 million. That's up from the 5 million listed in an earlier offer that small webcasters largely rejected, and increases to 9 million in 2011, and to 10 million for the 2012-2014 timeframe. Retroactively, the cap is 7 million for the 2006 - 2008 timeframe.

Also scuttling the earlier small webcaster settlement offer was a provision for payments should a small webcaster be acquired by a larger company. In the current offer, the acquiring company would have to pay the difference in royalties for up to four years retroactively if after the acquisition the new company makes more than $1.25 million a year, or 30% of the transaction value.

We at FMC take it as a positive sign that the parties involved have an upbeat view of the settlement. Plus we're pretty psyched that we can still listen to Pandora at work and know that artists are being compensated!

Tuesday, June 30, 2009

Just Plain Folks Announces JPF Music Awards Nominees



Now that we've gotten that pesky weekend out of the way, we wanted to tell you that Just Plain Folks have announced the nominees for the Just Plain Folks 2009 Music Awards.

For those unfamiliar, JPF (founded by FMC advisory board member, Brian Austin Whitney) is a website community comprising more than 51,500 songwriters, recording artists, publishers, record labels, producers and basically any other music-type, um, "folks." Their goal is simple: to help people involved in all levels of the music community network, share their experiences, build relationships and grow. JPF members have gone on to win Grammy’s, Emmys, CMA Awards and Academy Awards.

The largest independent music awards event on the planet, this year’s installment of the JPF Music Awards takes place on August 29 in Nashville, Tennessee. The 2009 “award cycle” saw submissions of more than 560,000 songs and 42,000 albums from 160-plus countries around the world. The final nominees span just about every conceivable genre —from rock, punk and country to hip hop, salsa and reggae. The awards are split into several general categories; the Founder's Awards, Song Awards, Album Awards, Video Awards, and Lyric Awards; from there the categories are then split further (although we didn’t see any emo-crunk-deathmetal-zydeco grouping).

We think the Just Plain Folks Music Awards are awesome because they help call attention to the hard work of so many independent musicians, and at an impressively wide-scale level. With extremely limited radio access and a crowded digital environment, today’s musicians have a lot of hurdles on the road to recognition, which is probably why the JPF Awards are such a hot ticket in the indie world.

Congrats to all the nominees and to JPF for all the effort they put into this event.

To check out the list of the 2009 nominees click here.

Tuesday, June 23, 2009

Erin McKeown Gets Cabin Fever in July


photo by jeff wasilko

We at FMC are always psyched when we hear about artists making DIY work for them. Although you can’t paint with one brush when it comes to musicians — many have wonderful relationships with their labels — it’s clear that today’s performers don’t need big-time backing to make a record and get it out there. And they're also getting way creative with marketing, as we point out in our recent post about Josh Freese and Jill Sobule.

Now, singer-songwriter Erin McKeown (who kicked ass at our most recent Artist Activism Camp and “Musicians Bringing Musicians Home” concert in New Orleans) is drumming up fan support to get her next record in the can and straight to her fans.

McKeown already has six albums and two EPs under her belt and has worked with über-respected artists like Ani DiFranco and Andrew Bird. For her next round of awesomeness, she’s offering fans the opportunity to watch a series of live internet concerts beginning this July called “Cabin Fever.”

The performances — which will include acoustic numbers, cover songs and an interactive, all-request electric set — will be broadcast from random places in and around Erin’s house. You know, hip venues like her living room, front porch and tour van! Proceeds from the project will go to the recording and release of her upcoming album, Hundreds of Lions, which is expected to drop later this year.

We wish Erin the best with what we think is a really cool idea. We’re also guessing that we’ll be seeing lots more of this kind of grassroots innovation from artists. That is, as long as net neutrality is preserved so that musicians have a direct connection to fans. For more information on Erin McKeown and the “Cabin Fever” project, check out her website. To learn more about how important the open internet is to artists, visit our Rock the Net page.

Friday, May 22, 2009

TuneCore Scores Spot at Amazon



TuneCore is one of a handful of companies (including CD Baby and ReverbNation) offering digital (and in some instances physical) distribution for the DIY musician. For a relatively small fee, artists using these services can get their tunes in all the major digital music sellers (iTunes, eMusic, Rhapody, etc.) — which means a coffeehouse strummer can be in the same "store" as Beyoncé. Pretty cool, huh? CD Baby will also handle the warehousing and mailorder for your physical discs, and most of these services provide referrals for custom-batch CD manufacturing.

Today, Digital Music News is reporting that TuneCore has made a deal with Amazon to have a special section within Amazon's MP3 store:

The TuneCore-branded environment will live within the broader AmazonMP3 site. Additionally, artists can offer custom-crafted CDs through Amazon partner CreateSpace. The action starts June 1st.

TuneCore already direct-ports downloads into a number of stores, including Amazon, iTunes, among many others. The store-within-a-store builds upon an existing partnership between TuneCore and Amazon, as does the CD-pressing component. The expansion helps TuneCore to expand its value proposition, though it also allows Amazon to breathe some life into its CreateSpace acquisition.

You may be familiar with CreateSpace, which grabs DIY by the long tail (ha!) and lets users self-publish books, music and movies to be stocked and sold through Amazon. We think it's great that more artists are able to use new services to get their creations out there, but if these services continue to take off, there will be that much more stuff to sift through. The question then becomes, what mechanisms can effectively facilitate discovery? Or to put it more simply, how do fans find what they like? Do they just randomly stumble upon it? Does the burden of marketing and promotion rest solely on the creator? How can developing artists most effectively cut through the noise?

In the past, labels handled much of an artist's promotion (PR firms also assist), but the game is changing for any number of reasons — the erosion of the physical CD market, unauthorized filesharing and the uncertainty around new models (like ad-supported and subscription services) — to name a few. For now, this could mean fewer acts get signed to traditional labels, and less money is available for promotion. It could also mean a future where industry entities become "all-in-one" services that provide a combination of marketing and promotion, live booking and tour management, recording and distribution and possibly even rights administration. The so-called "360 degree" deals that are popular with some superstar artists could represent a step in this direction.

But what about all the other artists out there? How will they cultivate and retain audiences? It's one thing to be able to make your stuff available, it's another to get the right people to find it. Magazines and radio have always acted as a kind of filter, but restrictive commercial radio playlists and the financial struggles of print (and online) media combined with the ever-increasing amount of music makes it tough for most artists to attract listeners. Obviously, reaching audiences was a challenge even back when the business of music was dominated by a system of bottlenecks and powerful gatekeepers. But there are new hurdles now that creative content is seemingly ubiquitous.

We're curious to hear your thoughts about the future of DIY and marketing in the digital age — feel free to leave a comment below. . .

Monday, April 20, 2009

Who Needs Earth Day When There’s Record Store Day?!?



Although many independent and mainstream music stores have closed over the years due to a decline in CD sales and general economic turbulence, there are those shops that have dug in their heels in the face of an increasingly technology-driven music industry. These survivors took part in the second annual Record Store Day, held this past Saturday (April 18) in stores all across the nation.

For those unfamiliar, Record Store Day is celebrated yearly on the third Saturday of April. On this fine day, the country’s independently owned record stores to come together with artists to celebrate the dazzling dance of music and commerce. This year, top acts like Franz Ferdinand, Erykah Badu and Ani DiFranco all gathered to pay homage to their hometown record stores while others like Bruce Springsteen, The Smiths and Modest Mouse offered limited special-edition vinyl releases for the occasion. As music junkies, we get pretty psyched about this “holiday,” so we figured we'd give you a little recap on how things went down in the District.

DC staples such as CD Warehouse, Crooked Beat Records, Melody Record Shop and Smash! all opened their doors to throngs of music fans who lined up hours before opening to get their hands on exclusive releases from their favorite artists. Melody Records, for instance, offered limited-edition seven-inches from the likes of Green Day and Jane’s Addiction, as well as reissues (although if you weren’t there early enough you could forget about those). Other treats included goodie bags filled with indie samplers, gift certificates, posters and discounted CDs.

Despite the success of Record Store Day, it’s still tough out there for music sellers. Just a couple of weeks ago it was announced that DC staple DJ Hut (known for their extremely awesome vinyl collections) will be closing its brick-and–mortar shop at the end of this month to become a strictly online record store. This trend has become all-too familiar to music fans these days.

On the upside, reports are suggesting that because of Record Store Day (and all of those cool exclusive releases) traffic and sales volume this year will eclipse the previous event. Which is very good news for independent retail owners (and musicians). Who says Christmas only comes once a year?

Tuesday, March 31, 2009

The New DIY?

There's been been a couple of online articles recently (that's one shy of three, which almost makes a trend!) about what "do-it-yourself" means in the era of digital music. So we figured we'd do a little thinking out loud, then turn the floor over to the experts — in other words, you.

With the advent of user-friendly digital distro services, musicians now have a wide array of relatively inexpensive tools to get their tunes out there. Of course, with fewer gatekeepers and the "democratization" of technology, it also means you probably have to work harder to get noticed — there's no slick suit who can make it magically happen for you. (And if there is, maybe s/he can give us a call?)

All of this upsets the traditional artist-record company relationship, which we've seen borne out by the increasing number of established acts who have ditched their labels in favor of more "experimental" approaches to marketing and distribution. (Insert tired Radiohead/Nine Inch Nails analogy here.)

But can an up-and-coming artist really be their own label? Superstars clearly have an advantage in terms of the critical mass needed to achieve success with direct-to-fan schemes — most have already benefited from "traditional" label arrangements during their developmental phase. So what does DIY mean for the struggling artist/part time barista?

It kind of depends who you ask.

Digital Music News published a piece this week called "DIY and the Death of the Rock Star." This paragraph basically explains their take:

Major labels no longer have the ability to generate huge blowouts, thanks partly to media fragmentation. Then again, direct-to-fan relationships have never been easier to build — one dedicated fan at a time. Indeed, those that toil to super-serve a core audience can reap the rewards, perhaps enough to quit the day job.

The article also cites indie-punk-cabaret goddess Amanda Palmer, who has become quite the Twitterer lately:

. . .despite the hype surrounding DIY, big questions continue to surround the ultimate payoff for unknown acts. Either way, artists can expect to dedicate extreme efforts and lots of connected time to achieve traction. "I'm spending a lot of time connecting with fans... and I don't feel as much of an artist as much as a promoter of Amanda Palmer," Palmer relayed. "All of this instant connection has taken the place of making art. An idea that might have translated into a song before might now go into my blog instead."

The quasi-snarky music/biz blog Idolator recently published a post with the awesome title, "Is DIY Just Another Word for Nothing Left to Lose?" FMC's founders can no doubt identify with this section:

The do-it-yourself attitude, conceived out of a combination of ambition and necessity, was revelatory to a particular generation who may have grown up with punk but still saw the movement's bands releasing albums on major labels; what started as adding a lower rung to the ladder became an end goal in itself, with labels like Dischord and K insisting that DIY techniques represented a way of making music that was anti-hierarchical, inclusive, and democratic. Artists who chose to subscribe to that particular philosophy became part of a system of mutual assistance which, at least theoretically, enabled them to make music without the need for a major label's resources.

In the current age, DIY seems to have reverted to being a stepping stone to greater success, whatever that might mean. Except that, instead of being a lower rung on the ladder, the DIY rung is rapidly becoming the entire ladder, at least to hear a lot of folks tell it.

The fragmentation of traditional gatekeepers, the changing role of labels, tough economic times and rampant file-sharing are all factors in what can only be described as a major paradigm shift in the business of music. But it's not all doom and gloom: increasingly artists can make their own career choices, from DIY tour booking to stocking music with digital retailers. Although it's probably too early to predict how all his will play out, FMC is planning a study of musician income streams that will hopefully provide a clearer picture about how these disruptions/opportunities are affecting artists' bottom lines.

We wouldn't want to call ourselves prescient or anything, but the other day (before the aforementioned articles were published), we conducted a non-scientific, "just for fun" experiment with our Twitter followers. We asked them "What does DIY mean to you?" and received a ton of interesting responses. Here's a handful:

ANTIQCOOL: Freedom! no suits telling me what to release.

talegends: DIY to me means "you know you can't afford to hire anyone, so if you want anything to happen you have to DIY!"

oastem: DIY means forging your own tools to follow your vision wherever it takes you be it over/underground.

travisnorman: DIY for me = The Freedom to pursue your vision precisely as you imagine it, without compromise.

Interestingly, no one said "too much damn work." Although one person seemed to take the question a bit too literally: "DIY means 'do it yourself,'" they said. Well, we're glad to have cleared that up!

If you haven't already chimed in, tell us in the comments what DIY means to you!

Thursday, March 26, 2009

Jill Sobule and Josh Freese Have Fun With Marketing



You don’t need us to tell you that economic times are tough — musicians are feeling the financial pinch just like anyone else. On the upside, they're getting really creative about how they make music and market themselves. From a personal "lunch date" at the Cheesecake Factory to a live performance in your living room, today's artists are doing whatever it takes to establish a fanbase and hopefully sell some music.

As David Byrne (who actually appeared at our 2006 Policy Summit) once sang, “same as it ever was.”

Or is it? Musicians like Josh Freese and Jill Sobule are taking the artist-fan relationship to a whole new level. Both musicians have had pretty solid careers — Freese is a drummer who’s recorded albums with Nine Inch Nails, Devo and A Perfect Circle ( to name a few); Sobule is a songwriter who sang about “kissing a girl” back when Katy Perry was still in Junior High. And both have new albums out and are inviting fans to play a more direct (and atypical) role in their success.

Like many musicians, Sobule has had a rocky relationship with record labels. After being dropped by two majors and living through the bankruptcy of two indies, she decided in 2008 to take matters into her own hands. Sobule started a fundraising drive to help record her next album. And what rewards her benefactors would receive: t-shirts, a personalized voicemail theme song, live performances at fans’ pads and, for the right price, the chance to contribute background vocal to her album. ”If you can’t sing, no problem — we can fix it on our end,” she said. Sobule raised an astounding $75,000, which she used to make her record and is now hoping the buzz will help generate CD sales. (Check out an interview with her here.)

In-demand drummer Freese claims his last CD sold somewhere between “three to five copies” but he’s hoping that his latest disc will do a lot better, thanks in part to his new marketing strategy (somewhat old news, but still awesome).

Freese is counting on his connections with industry vets and a passion for “fine dining” to help move units. Ever wondered what Pearl Jam guitarist Stone Gossard’s favorite song is? Well, if you cough up $500 for Freese, he’ll have Stone personally write you a letter letting you know. Crave a three-course meal at the Cheesecake Factory with Mr. Freese himself? If you can cough up $250.00 your dream can come true. And if you have $75,000 that Bernie Madoff didn’t get to, you, Freese and Danny Carey from Tool can all trip on ‘shrooms and ride around in Carey’s Lamborghini (people, we are NOT making this up!) What hedge-funder wouldn’t jump at such a unique opportunity?

All jokes aside, the “new DIY” is changing the way musicians are selling their wares and getting attention in a noisy media landscape. It's also cool to see musicians finding humor in an industry saddled with declining sales and finger pointing. Maybe even laughing all the way to the bailed-out bank.

Monday, January 26, 2009

Meet the Policy Day Panelists: Derek Sivers


Derek Sivers

With so many cool and interesting panelists on board for our upcoming DC Policy Day (February 11!) it’s hard to choose which guest to be more excited over. That said, there is one speaker that every musician attending should take special note of: Derek Sivers, founder of CD Baby and the mind behind DIY music info hub Sivers.org.

For those of you who don’t know, Sivers founded CD Baby in after quitting his job at Warner Music to become a full time musician. Instead of trying to score a record deal and conventional distribution, Sivers began selling his CD on his personal website. Soon he was helping his musician friends do the same, and CD Baby was born. Since those humble beginnings, the site has grown to include more than 267,000 acts, sold more than five million CDs to online customers and has paid more than 98 million dollars directly to artists (whoa!).

No doubt those are impressive numbers. But in 2008 Sivers decided to move on from CD Baby in order to focus on informing and inspiring indie musicians at Sivers.org. (Did we mention that prior to all of this he toured with the circus as a ringleader/musician? And that he's never tried coffee?)

So with CD Baby, Warner Music and the circus behind him, this FMC Board member following through with his mission. Through his website, Sivers offers numerous projects to help out the everyday musician trying to pursue their art and hopefully earn a buck.

From his free e-book full of tips on how to successfully promote your music to MuckWork, a concept involving the outsourcing of promotional and design chores, Sivers is always dreaming up ways to help musicians become more empowered and self-sufficient. Particularly interesting is his grassroots music biz documentary, which lets musicians interview magazine writers, club promoters and radio programmers (to name a few) to better understand the how the gears turn.

Sivers will be moderating a panel at Policy Day ’09 called “Fair Trade Music: Toward a Legitimate Digital Music Marketplace,” which also features legendary British manager and artist advocate Peter Jenner and Pandora founder Tim Westergren (they’ll be joined by one more soon-to-be-named individual). Expect a fascinating conversation about new applications and technologies that help musicians promote and sell their music, and how policy decisions affect the viability of these sites and services.

As always, we’ll be offering a limited number of musician scholarships to Policy Day; click here to apply!

Wednesday, January 21, 2009

A2IM's Rich Bengloff in Huffington Post


If you've been following FMC's work, you've no doubt heard us talk about the American Association of Independent Music (A2IM) — a forward-looking non-profit organization that represents a broad coalition of independent labels.

A2IM has gone to bat on a number of important issues, including making commercial radio friendlier to independent artists — an effort FMC wholeheartedly supports. In fact, we recently collaborated with A2IM on a report about how indie labels are still having difficulty getting airplay on commercial radio a year after the "Rules of Engagement" with major station groups. (These voluntary agreements were a result of 2006-2007 payola investigations; for more info see our Payola Education Guide.)

On January 15, A2IM President Rich Bengloff published "An Indie Music Memo to the FCC: We Need a Level Playing Field Too" at the Huffington Post. The article calls on the Commission to recognize the indie sector's contribution to the music economy (around 30 percent of all domestic music sold), and says that access to the digital marketplace is crucial to indie artists and labels. That means net neutrality — the principle that protects the open internet — must be preserved. (For more info on net neutrality and the music community, visit FMC's Rock the Net page.)

Bengloff also underscores the need to properly compensate musicians for their creative efforts:

Everyone who embraces the digital model now has access to a global market and can compete. Intellectual Property in general, and music specifically, are big contributors to our economy -- and to our culture. Making certain that open and fair access to market is maintained while supporting fair compensation for the use of music is the worthwhile and achievable goal.

That pretty much hits the nail on the head. Achieving this goal isn't exactly easy, but you can count on groups like A2IM and FMC to keep working towards it nonetheless. You could say the future of music depends on it!

Thursday, November 6, 2008

Ch-Ch-Ch-Changes?



In case you hadn't noticed, there was a big ol' election last Tuesday, the results of which have Washington, D.C. (and the rest of the country, not to mention the world) buzzing. But what will a Barack Obama Administration and a new Democratic Congress mean for the music community?

We at FMC are expecting a positive impact on the music world in general. Keep in mind that we're equal opportunity wonks — our assessment is not partisan. But it is informed by the policy decisions of the last eight years, which created or maintained significant barriers to sustainable cultural communities.

There will now be opportunities to craft policies that encourage the flourishing of music across media platforms. From expanded community radio to more robust commercial broadcasting and broadband, musicians will likely benefit from more attention paid to the ways in which they reach potential audiences, and ultimately earn a living.

Check out FMC Analysis: Election Impact on Artists and the Music Community for a point-by-point look at what we think are the key areas for improvement. Then let us know what issues are most important to you in the comments field of this post.

Monday, October 27, 2008

Being Your Own Marketer



Today's post at the Copyright Alliance blog got us thinking about how today's musicians develop a fan base. The digital revolution has led to unprecedented ways to connect with potential audiences, but the landscape can be tricky to navigate.

If there's any consensus about what you need to succeed, it's probably much the same as back in the analog era. Talent (even if it's currently only your mom or GF/BF who thinks you've got it) and persistence are still your best bet. The good news is that you've got tons of tools to start convincing the rest of the world.

While there's no shortage of new technologies to promote and distribute your work, getting going can seem daunting. FMC talked about ways to get your music out there at our "What's the Future for Musicians?" events in Chicago and New York City (as well as our earlier seminars in upstate NY) — we'll be archiving the presentations online as soon as they're available.

In the meantime, here are a few interesting places you can visit to learn how to "market yourself."

FMC Advisory Board member Derek Sivers is a hero to many for having started CD Baby — a service that's helped countless indie musicians sell physical discs and get their stuff in digital stores. Derek recently sold the company, but he hasn't given up on helping artists promote their work. His site has tons of DIY tips for musicians, which he's constantly refining and adding to.

Randy Chertkow and Jason Feehan are the authors of a book called The Indie Band Survival Guide, and they also run a website of the same name. (We got to meet Jason in person at our Chicago seminar). The book you have to pay for, but the PDF that it's based on is still free. The site has tons of information about tools you can use to promote your music.

Ariel Hyatt is a publicity expert who appeared at our Big Apple event. Her main site is here. (She's also got a new book called Music Success in Nine Weeks.)

David Rose has a blog called Know the Music Biz that's full of good tips.

It used to be you pretty much needed to have a label or distributor (or spend a lot of time consigning stuff at individual record shops) to get your tunes to retail. Nowadays, you can "stock" your music with all the leading digital stores for a nominal charge. There's the aforementioned CD Baby, which includes digital servicing when they stock your physical disc (you can also opt for digital-only), TuneCore (which also offers CD duplication and marketing tips) and ReverbNation — which recently went from being just a streaming player to a full-service digital distributor.

Of course, once you've made your music available, you gotta let people know about it. Today's artists have a lot of different means to do so — podcasts and webcasts (either their own or other people's), blogs, social network sites and online "radio" stations like Pandora and last.fm. And let's not forget good-old-fashioned terrestrial radio. Indie artists may be mostly locked out of commercial stations, but there are stil plenty of opportunities with non-commercial, Low-Power FM and college broadcasters.

The bottom line is that you've got great deal more opportunity to self-promote than at any other time in history. This might mean a lot of work that doesn't seem to fit into the "rock star" stereotype of boundless leisure. But it also means more control over your musical destiny — something pretty rare in the days of bottlenecks, gatekeepers and middlemen. (If you think musicians should be able to make their own choices about how their music is distributed online, you should check out our Rock the Net campaign for net neutrality.)

Of course, we're curious: what are some of YOUR favorite means to promote your music?

Thursday, October 23, 2008

Payola and Indie Access to Commercial Airwaves




As part of our ongoing work to improve the state of terrestrial radio and create more opportunities for artists to reach potential audiences, FMC has worked closely with the American Association of Independent Music (A2IM) — a group that represents a broad coalition of independent labels — to determine whether independently-released music is reaching the commercial airwaves.

Having observed trends in terrestrial radio since the turn of the millennium, we realize two things: a) consolidation in station ownership after the 1996 Telecommunications Act has led to a loss of independent owners and local control over programming decisions at commercial stations, and b) pay-for-play schemes like payola have made it incredibly difficult for non-major label talent to score commercial radio play.

While consolidation still remains a problem, attempts have been made to curb payola. In 2003, then-New York Attorney General Eliot Spitzer launched an investigation into whether the nation’s biggest radio chains were participating in payola. The answer was a resounding yes. Spitzer uncovered blatant pay-for-play arrangements, including major label inducements and a corrupt system of middlemen (independent promoters) who acted as gatekeepers to commercial programming. (You can read some of Spitzer’s published evidence here, or learn more about the history of payola and the NY AG investigations in our Payola Education Guide.)

While Spitzer's probe resulted in consent decrees and the collection of over $30 million in fines from the four major labels, it was up to the FCC to complete the investigation on radio stations. In March 2007, the FCC decided to settle with the four largest radio station groups that had been accused of engaging in payola – CBS, Citadel, Clear Channel and Entercom. Although the agency was successful in collecting small fines from the station group owners and implementing consent decrees, the FCC resisted calls for oversight, leaving no means through which to guarantee implementation or compliance. So, the independent music community – led by A2IM and FMC – helped implement a separate set of voluntary "Rules of Engagement" with the broadcasting chains. The hope was to create the conditions for a more productive relationship between the indies and the major broadcasters.

So where are we, some 18 months later?

A new survey of A2IM label members conducted by investigative journalist (and former FMC Communications Director) Justin Jouvenal found that indie labels are still having difficulty getting airplay on commercial radio.

A2IM sent out a 42-question survey to its label membership, which asked about whether their relationship with commercial radio had changed over the last year. The report, which was released on October 20, 2008, at an A2IM-sponsored roundtable discussion in New York City, revealed near-unanimous sentiment among label owners; little has changed over the last year and a half, with 92 percent of label respondents describing their relationship to commercial radio as “the same” as before the Consent Decree and Voluntary Agreements. You can see the press announcement here; read the report here; and download the full report with appendices (PDF) here.

FMC continues to research, analyze and document commercial radio play to better understand if and when independent music is played on corporate radio. At the same time, we continue to push for and support non-commercial and Low-Power FM as an alternative to the homogenized sounds heard on commercial stations. We also believe that, for terrestrial radio to be viable in the 21st century, it must reaffirm its commitments to serving the communities in which it holds licenses. In other words, it needs to think, program, and act locally. In this way, we hope to rebuild the vital connections between listeners, artists, labels and programmers so everyone can benefit from the public airwaves.

For more information on radio issues, visit our articles and research pages.

Thursday, March 20, 2008

"What's the Future for Musicians?" — New York State Music Education Seminars


What's the Future for Musicians?


We've been meaning to make mention of a series of exciting (and free) events we're co-hosting in New York State throughout the month of April. But we've been so busy planning that we almost forgot to blog about them. Here's the official skinny:

Today’s music landscape is filled with both excitement and foreboding. With so many new technologies and ways to promote and distribute music, how do performers, composers, songwriters and independent labels know how to participate, who to trust and what is most effective?

FMC is partnering with American Federation of Musicians locals and other artist organizations around New York State to host free, daylong forums in Buffalo, Syracuse and Albany throughout April 2008.

These free seminars are designed educate musicians and label owners from a range of genres – classical, jazz, rock, folk and hip-hop – about the critical issues at the intersection of music, law, technology and policy, with the goal of better preparing musicians to participate in the issues that affect their livelihood.

The first of these events takes place in Buffalo on Wednesday April 2, at Livingston Hall (inside Kleinhans Music Hall). Click here for more information, and to RSVP.

Visit the main website to check out dates and programming for all of the events.

Hope to see you there!

Tuesday, March 18, 2008

Radio Robots to Help Indie Artists Get Airplay?



We found an interesting article in the latest edition of Wired about a new system for indie acts to deliver tracks to radio stations that rely on automation to manage their playlists. Well, it's not a new system, exactly — major labels and commercial radio have been using it for years.

As Wired scribe Eliot Van Buskirk writes, "indie musicians have been at a disadvantage when it comes to delivering music to larger stations. . . because the major labels use something called Digital Media Distribution System (DMDS) to send new tracks to stations digitally and securely (to minimize leaks)."

That's not the only reason indie musicians have had difficulty getting on the corporate airwaves. Payola, both institutional and in-your-face, has made it near-impossible for anyone but the best financed (and ethically compromised) musicians and labels to breach the commercial radio wall. Even when compelled by the FCC to air independent acts, massive radio conglomerates have tried to require artists to sign away their rights to digital royalties in exchange for airplay consideration. FMC exposed such behavior by Clear Channel in a series of blog posts last year.

According to Wired, a company called Yangaroo (which also services major labels) is now offering an indie-centric version of its DMDS technology. The general understanding is that most folks at commercial radio are loathe to open padded brown envelopes, so digital delivery could result in more spins for the indies.

That's the theory anyway.

FMC is working on a Payola Education Guide that will help musicians understand the historical context of this disingenuous practice, and offer advice about what can be done about it. We're also busy tracking playlists in order to determine which stations are playing indie music and how often. So stay, um, tuned.

Thursday, February 21, 2008

No Depression is No More.

After 13 solid years, alt-country magazine No Depression is moseying off into the sunset. Fans of the publication — which helped break the careers of artists like Ryan Adams and Wilco — are understandably bummed, as are many of the niche acts the mag covered.

This article from The News & Observer was written by onetime ND scribe David Menconi. It's a pretty good eulogy.

What's behind the shutdown of one of the most beloved rags in American music? Shrinking advertising revenue, for one. But publishers Grant Alden, Peter Blackstock and Kyla Fairchild also point to a changing media and retail environment as factors in their decision. Here's an excerpt of the announcement from the most recent issue:

Those circumstances are both complicated and painfully simple. The simple answer is that advertising revenue in this issue is 64% of what it was for our March- April issue just two years ago. We expect that number to continue to decline.

The longer answer involves not simply the well-documented and industrywide reduction in print advertising, but the precipitous fall of the music industry. As a niche publication, ND is well insulated from reductions in, say, GM's print advertising budget; our size meant they weren't going to buy space in our pages, regardless.

On the other hand, because we're a niche title we are dependent upon advertisers who have a specific reason to reach our audience. That is: record labels. We, like many of our friends and competitors, are dependent upon advertising from the community we serve.

That community is, as they say, in transition. In this evolving downloadable world, what a record label is and does is all up to question. What is irrefutable is that their advertising budgets are drastically reduced, for reasons we well understand. It seems clear at this point that whatever businesses evolve to replace (or transform) record labels will have much less need to advertise in print.

The decline of brick and mortar music retail means we have fewer newsstands on which to sell our magazine, and small labels have fewer venues that might embrace and hand-sell their music. Ditto for independent bookstores. . .

What makes the news particularly, um, depressing is that the magazine still has a loyal readership and high sell-through rates. But that's apparently not enough to offset the losses in ad revenue.

No Depression will continue to operate its website, but readers only have one more physical issue to look forward to. And the independent Americana, folk and country acts who have come to depend on the magazine for publicity will no doubt have a tougher trail to tread.

Wednesday, February 13, 2008

Blog Hype and Album Sales — Fact or Fiction?


A new study by NYU/Stern professor Vasant Dhar indicates that blog buzz has a strong correlation with album sales. The study looked at blog posts, changes in an artist's number of MySpace friends, and online album reviews over an eight-week period — half before an album was released, half after.

The study found that increases in MySpace friends had a slight positive correlation to album sales. More significantly, artists who received ample attention from major blogs seemed to "move more units," as they say in the biz.

Marketing budgets were also factored in, with major label artists performing better than their indie counterparts. However, artists on smaller labels could overcome this disadvantage with sufficient buzz. The magic number of blog posts to achieve online semi-stardom is apparently 240. Something to shoot for!

All of this number-crunching proves something that we all know intuitively — the more you're talked about, the more albums you'll sell. But you have to wonder about cause and effect: do better-selling albums receive more attention in blogs simply because the artists already have a higher profile? The study doesn't analyze whether the blog mentions are positive or negative, so you can't tell if blogs are truly tastemakers, or merely indicators of an artist's existing popularity.

Along those lines, the number of MySpace friends a band has may be the result of of higher real-world sales rather than the cause. And, there's also anecdotal evidence of a backlash when a band is overhyped by blogs before they even get to release an album. Indie-rockers Black Kids are an example of this phenomenon, according to snarky music-news site Idolator.

So should bands view blogs as a potentially powerful marketing tool? The results are inconclusive. But the study does indicate that blogs and MySpace have a role to play in exposure and sales. So you might wanna keep e-mailing those tunes and adding more friends.

Wednesday, January 23, 2008

Rehearsal Room Blues

Many of you may have seen the article in today's New York Times about the lack of affordable rehearsal space in the Big Apple. The problem, while hardly new, is getting worse due to skyrocketing real estate prices.

The story cites figures from nycMusicSpaces.org, which is operated by NYC nonprofit NYC Arts Spaces. The group claims that 44 percent of musicians in NYC make less than $50,000 a year, and they're often forced to cut corners on basic living expenses in order to pursue their art. Places to perform are also becoming more scarce, as rents and operating costs for venues continue to rise.

New York City has a reputation for being expensive, but it would be a major blow to the city's cultural character if musicians are priced out of playing.

FMC is planning a series of educational gatherings for musicians in New York State in April. We’ll be talking about everything from payola to net neutrality, but also hope to hear from artists about their experiences with securing rehearsal spaces. Stay tuned for more info on those events.

Wednesday, December 19, 2007

Still Making Sense



If there's anyone who knows how to survive in the music industry, it's David Byrne. From his days on the NYC underground with the Talking Heads, to running a label and touring the world as a solo artist, Byrne has seen pretty much every side of the business. He's also revered by a younger generation of indie musicians, who look up to him as a role model of artistry and integrity.

Now he's offering his opinions on how musicians can survive in an increasingly unstable music world. Byrne recently wrote an article in Wired, entitled "David Byrne's Survival Strategies for Emerging Artists — and Megastars."

In it, Byrne suggests that the crisis facing the industry's old guard, while disruptive to a certain status quo, need not spell doom for working musicians.

“What is called the music business today is not the business of producing music. At some point it became the business of selling CDs in plastic cases, and that business will soon be over. But that's not bad news for music, and it's certainly not bad news for musicians. Indeed, with all the ways to reach an audience, there have never been more opportunities for artists. Where are things going?”

The online version of the article also features audio of Byrne's chats with forward-thinking artist/producer Brian Eno and Merge Records co-owner Mac McCaughan, as well as a link to a separate back-and-forth with Radiohead's Thom Yorke.

Byrne delivered a presentation at FMC's 2006 Policy Summit called "Record Companies: Who Needs Them?" McCaughan, too, is a Policy Summit veteran, and also testified before the Senate Commerce Committee at its October "Future of Radio" hearing.)

With so much insecurity and backbiting among the music business elite, it's refreshing to hear a more proactive response to this period of transition. Especially coming from someone as cool as David Byrne.

Thursday, December 13, 2007

No Label? No Problem.


A couple of indie-music veterans and their managers have come together to create a new music site that "will allow artists to release new music, and create deeper relationships with fans, who can create remixes and spend up to $5,000 to get an executive producer credit on an artist's album," according to an article in DigitalMediaWire.

Krstin Hersh (Throwing Muses) and Donita Sparks (L7) recently launched CASH: Coalition for Artists and Stake Holders. Apart from a new Hersh single, there's not too much on offer at the moment, but Hersh states on her blog that the site will "soon be open to any and all independent artists who want a set of tools to offer their music directly to their audience for collaboration as well as financial support."

There are a lot of digital-distribution services cropping up lately, but this one is interesting in a few different ways. Firstly, it aims to foster more dynamic connection between creator and consumer by providing the master tracks from songs, to be reinterpreted by fans and shared among the CASH community.

The concept of user-generated remixes isn't entirely new: Trent Reznor debuted a similar web-based project not long ago, only to have his ex-label, Universal Music, pull the plug over copyright worries. Reznor's response was to relaunch the site on his own servers.

As creator-owners, CASH artists aren't likely to run into that problem. The site is also offering a "pay-what-you-want" MP3 of Hersh's new single, administered under a Creative Commons license. Perhaps we haven't heard the last of the much-ballyhooed Radiohead pricing model.

And there's more "value-added" for CASH patrons:

. . .fans of Hersh's music can choose one of a number of "subscription" plans, ranging from $10 per quarter, for which they get a sticker, poster, CD and downloads; to $30, which includes a "Works in Progress" CD sampler, as well as guest list +1 to one of her shows.

For $500, fans will get a visit with Hersh in the recording studio, while $1,000 will earn them a "Featured Sponsor" credit, and $5,000 an "Executive Producer" credit on her next album.

This idea is certainly interesting. A similar dynamic exists at ArtistShare, where musicians can manage and develop a "tiered" relationship with fans. There are varying degrees of personalized access — including studio visits, executive producer credits and signed merch — depending on the level of donation. Progressive big band composer Maria Schneider is one of that site's finest talents and greatest success stories.

As many traditional labels continue to flounder, will we see more artist-fan patronage arrangements in the future?

Tuesday, May 15, 2007

The new indie artist

The New York Times Magazine had an interesting piece over the weekend on how musicians are building new distribution networks and fan bases via the Internet.

The piece kicks off by profiling Jonathan Coulton, a former computer programmer and unsigned Brooklyn indie artist who is making a "reasonable middle class living" by selling CDs and music downloads via his web site, iTunes, and CD Baby. Coulton built a fan base by recording a song a week for all of 2006 and then posting them on his blog. They ranged from odes to Tom Cruise ("Tom Cruise Crazy") to pieces about the dead-end life of a programmer ("Code Monkey").

Coulton managed to get 3,000 people a day visiting his web site and as many as 500,000 downloads of some of his songs. Not only has the Internet changed the music business model, it has changed the way artists interact with fans. Coulton spends hours each day e-mailing with fans and blogging.

This is not a trend that affects A-list stars. The most famous corporate acts — Justin Timberlake, Fergie, Beyoncé — are still creatures of mass marketing, carpet-bombed into popularity by expensive ad campaigns and radio airplay. They do not need the online world to find listeners, and indeed, their audiences are too vast for any artist to even pretend intimacy with. No, this is a trend that is catalyzing the B-list, the new, under-the-radar acts that have always built their success fan by fan. Across the country, the CD business is in a spectacular free fall; sales are down 20 percent this year alone. People are increasingly getting their music online (whether or not they’re paying for it), and it seems likely that the artists who forge direct access to their fans have the best chance of figuring out what the new economics of the music business will be.
...
But the B-list increasingly includes a newer and more curious life-form: performers like Coulton, who construct their entire business model online. Without the Internet, their musical careers might not exist at all. Coulton has forgone a record-label contract; instead, he uses a growing array of online tools to sell music directly to fans. He contracts with a virtual fulfillment house called CD Baby, which warehouses his CDs, processes the credit-card payment for each sale and ships it out, while pocketing only $4 of the album’s price, a much smaller cut than a traditional label would take. CD Baby also places his music on the major digital-music stores like iTunes, Rhapsody and Napster. Most lucratively, Coulton sells MP3s from his own personal Web sites, where there’s no middleman at all.

The writer, Clive Thompson, assigns these artists, like Coulton, the rather moth-eaten title of Artist 2.0. (Can we finally retire 2.0 as a way of describing something or someone exploiting new technology?!?) Despite the hackneyed terminology, Thompson rightly recognizes how the Internet has revolutionized the music industry and really opened up a whole new set of opportunities for the indie artist. There's some great ideas in this piece for people looking to promote their music online.